International Journal of Epidemiology, Vol 22, S127-S133, Copyright © 1993 by International Epidemiological Association
I Belletti, L Troschel, P Pisani and F Berrino
The validity of retrospective assessment of occupational exposure greatly
depends on the amount of detail in the available information, on the
knowledge of the specific industrial process by the experts, and on the
criteria adopted to define relevant exposure. These criteria are difficult
to standardize and are rarely made explicit in published reports, which
makes it difficult to interpret inconsistencies among different studies. In
two ongoing case-control studies on kidney cancer and, respectively,
malignant lymphomas, a detailed occupational history was obtained and
supplemented by 19 additional questionnaires, specifically addressing
industrial activities where the knowledge of job title alone would have
been insufficient for reliable exposure assessment. One further
questionnaire was used to collect details of task and environment for all
the other activities. These data are used to establish probability,
intensity and frequency of exposure to 30 substances known or suspected to
be carcinogenic from previous studies. There are two basic steps in the
exposure assessment procedure: firstly, general rules are defined for each
job within each activity covered by specific questionnaires; secondly the
judgement is modulated according to the detailed tasks, working conditions
and environment. To illustrate the process and to facilitate comparison
with other studies, examples are given for a few common exposures in the
textile and metal industries--the two most frequent economic activities in
the study area- -namely exposure to mineral oils, formaldehyde, aromatic
solvents, chlorinated solvents and other organic solvents.
ARTICLES
Retrospective assessment of exposure by experts: the example of formaldehyde, solvents and mineral oils among textile and metal workers
Epidemiology Division, Istituto Nazionale dei Tumori, Milan, Italy.
![]()
CiteULike
Connotea
Del.icio.us What's this?